A Comparison Study on Various Finite Element Models of Riveted Lap Joint by the Use of Dynamic Model Updating

Document Type : Original Article


1 Aerospace Engineering Department, Shahid Sattari Aeronautical University of Science and Technology, Azadi Sq., Tehran, Iran.

2 Department of Aerospace Engineering, Shahid Sattari Aeronautical University of Science and Technology, Tehran , Iran


Till now, various models have been proposed in literature to simulate the behavior of riveted structures. In order to find the most accurate analytical method in modeling the dynamic behavior of riveted structures, a comparison study is performed on several of these models, in this research. For this purpose, experimental modal analysis tests are conducted on a riveted plate to verify the efficacy of the analytical models. Moreover, finite element model updating is used to reduce the difference between analytical and experimental results. First, the material properties of plates are optimized using the experimental results obtained from modal tests of a simple plate. Next, the optimization is performed for the physical properties of rivet. At the end, it is concluded that the fastener model proposed by Rutman can bring about the most accurate results when it is used in combination with solid plates and gap elements in the contact region.


Main Subjects

Article Title [فارسی]

A Comparison Study on Various Finite Element Models of Riveted Lap Joint by the Use of Dynamic Model Updating

Keywords [فارسی]

  • Rivet
  • Riveted Plates
  • Modal Parameters
  • Finite element model updating
[1]    Song Y, Hartwigsen CJ, McFarland DM and Vakakis AF (2004) Simulation of dynamics of beam structures with bolted joints using adjusted Iwan beam elements, Journal of Sound and Vibration, 273: 249-276.
[2]    Ibrahim RA and Pettit CL (2005) Uncertainties and dynamic problems of bolted joints and other fasteners, Journal of Sound and Vibration 279: 857-936.
[3]    Ahmadian H and Jalali H (2007) Identification of bolted lap joints parameters in assembled structures, Mechanical Systems and Signal Processing 21: 1041-1050.
[4]    Singh B and Nanda BK (2012) Estimation of damping in layered welded structures with unequal thickness, Shock and Vibration 19: 1463-1475.
[5]    Khattak AR (2012) A new approach for the linearization of dynamics in bolted joints, Journal of Aerospace Engineering, 227.
[6]    Palmonella M, Friswell MI, Mottershead JE and Lees AW (2005) Finite element models of spot welds in structural dynamics: review and updating, Journal of Computers and Structures, 83: 648-661.
[7]    Husain NA, Khodaparast HH, Snaylam A, James S, Dearden G and Quyang H (2010) Finite element modeling and updating of laser spot weld joints in a top-hat structure for dynamic analysis, Journal of Mechanical Engineering Science, 224.
[8]    Gant F, Rouch PH, Louf F and Champaney L (2011) Definition and updating of simplified models of joint stiffness, International Journal of Solids and Structures, 48: 775-784.
[9]    Zang C, Ma S and Friswell MI (2013) Finite element model updating of an assembled aero-engine casing, Topics in Model Validation and Uncertainty Qualification, 5: 199-212.
[10] Zhai X, Fei CW, Wang JJ and Yao XY (2016) Parametric modeling and updating for bolted joints of aero-engine casings, Journal of Mechanical Engineering Science, 230.
[11] Dourado MDM and de Meireles JFB (2014) A Simplified Finite Element Riveted Lap Joint Model in Structural Dynamic Analysis, Advanced Materials Research 1016: 185-191.
[12] Huang JW and Sin HF (2001) Aluminum rail rivet and steel rail weld DOE and CAE studies for NVH, SAE Technical Paper, 1608.
[13] Rahman HA,  Khairi NDA and  Sani MSM (2019) Finite Element Model Updating of Dissimilar Plate with Rivet Joint, Journal of Physics: Conference Series1262.
[14] Körük H and Şanlıtürk KY (2007) Validation of finite element models of structures with riveted joints using vibration data, In: INTER-NOISE Conference, Istanbul, Turkey, 28-31 August.
[15] Naarayan SS, Kumar DVTGP and Chandra S (2009) Implication of unequal rivet load distribution in the failures and damage tolerant design of metal and composite civil aircraft riveted lap joints, Engineering Failure Analysis, 16(7): 2255–2273,.
[16] Brewer BA (2012) Simplified Modeling Methods for Mechanically Fastened Connections in Flight Structures, MSc Thesis, University of California, San Diego.
[17] Atre A and Johnson WS (2006) Effect of Interference on the Mechanics of Load Transfer in Aircraft Fuselage Lap Joints, Journal of Engineering Materials and Technology, 129: 356-366.
[18] Yunus MA,  Abdul RaniMN, SaniMSM and  Aziz ShahMAS (2018) Finite element model updating of riveted joints of simplified model aircraft structure, American Institute of Physics conference Series.
[19] Zhan M,  Guo Q, Yue L and  Zhang B,(2018) Modeling and Stochastic Model Updating of Bolt-Jointed Structure, Shock And Vibration.
[20] Xiong Y and Bedair OK (1999) Analytical and Finite Element Modeling of Riveted Lap Joints in Aircraft Structure, AIAA Journal, 37: 93-99.
[21] Wronicz W and Kaniowski J (2009) Methods for global and local FEM analysis of riveted joints on the example of the PZL M2 sky-truck aircraft, Fatigue of Aircraft Structures, 1: 212-225.
[22] Rutman A, Boshers C, Pearce L and Parady J (2007) Fastener modeling for Joining parts modeled by shell and solid Elements, In: Americas Virtual Product Development Conference, Detroit, USA, 11-12 October.
[23] Shokrollahi S and  Adel F (2016) Finite element model updating of bolted lap joints implementing identification of joint affected region parameters, Journal of Theatrical and Applied Vibration and Acoustics 2:65-78.